Find out how Path Interactive can deliver a customized approach to growing your business.
Please tell us about yourself and we'll contact you shortly.

Who Talks the Best Trash? New York Giants vs. New England Patriots

Sarah Fonseca Dryden January 30, 2012 Category Social Media

Social Media: Super Bowl Negative Sentiment Analysis

Who’s the best at trash talking – New Yorkers, or Bostonians?

With Super Bowl Sunday coming up in just a few days, our office decided to take a look at the conversations happening around the big game and prove exactly how well each team’s fan base talks trash.

To do this, we started the week running up to the Superbowl by examining conversations happening on Facebook, Twitter, blogs, forums, news sites, and other social hubs. We specifically were interested in how much (and how brutally) fans from each East Coast team were dissing and dismissing each other, so we first got to work identifying the most common insults.

Patriots Bash - TwitterIt turns out the most common football insults are pretty predictable.




“Suck,” “lose,” “beat,” “hate,” as well as a few choice four-letter words turn out to be the most common themes in sports-themed internet dissing, so we formulated a study that looked for each team’s name in conjunction with these specific negative word associations. Also included in our net were team-specific put-downs, such as fans calling the New England Patriots the “Patsies,” or the New York Giants the “Midgets.”Patriots Bash - Facebook

Annoying Giants Fans - TwitterForming these studies turns out to be a lot harder than we imagined, since most fans tend to mention both teams in the same sentence along with at least one negative keyword. That makes it hard to filter negative sentiments aimed towards one specific team, since comments like “Patriots suck! Giants will win!” looks similar in search to “Giants suck! Patriots will win!” This makes the ordering of keywords in these queries vital.

Hate Both Teams - TwitterIt also turns out that quite a few people aren’t excited to see either team. We saw quite a few angry commenters upset that the Cowboys, 49ers, or Packers weren’t in the Superbowl. (We decided to count equal-opportunity trash-talkers for the purposes of our study.)

On Day 1 of our study (the Monday before Superbowl Sunday), both fan bases seem to be laying down the smack talk with equal passion. Patriots fans appear to have a slight edge today, with ONE extra negative comment to take the win.Super Bowl Negative Sentiment - VolumeSuper Bowl Negative Sentiment - MediaVengeful Patriots fans also seem to take to Twitter more than Giants fans, while more ruthless Giants fans than Patriots use Facebook.

Stay tuned this week as the Superbowl XLVI gets closer – we’ll be watching to see how the insults start flying, and we’ll be sharing or favorites along with ongoing social insights.

Day 2: Patriots Fans Ramp Up Insults As Super Bowl Gets Closer

Day 3: Patriots Players Much More Interesting Than Giants Players…

Day 4: All This Brady-Bashing Getting Out of Hand

Day 5: Yeah, New Yorkers Really Are Rude

Most Recent

How to Build a Data-Driven Business Case for Content

By Paul VanHevel, PathInteractive | September 16, 2016

A Step-by-Step Guide to Quantifying the Value of Content In the sometimes-gray world of organic search marketing, conveying the value of your […]

Read More

The Science Behind Data-Driven Attribution, Google’s New Attribution Model

By Steven Sonnes, PathInteractive | August 5, 2016

When shopping online customers often touch multiple marketing channels before they convert. In marketing this is known as the consumer […]

Read More

The New Mad Men: Looking Back at Advertising’s Evolution Towards Digital Marketing

By Ann Paskor, PathInteractive | July 19, 2016

Everyone in the marketing world has heard of Mad Men. They were the cool guys in the 60’s who worked […]

Read More